Skip to product information

Traditional Key Lime Pie

Traditional Key Lime Pie

 (302 Reviews)
Regular price $29.99
Regular price $29.99 Sale price
SAVE Liquid error (snippets/price line 116): Computation results in '-Infinity'% Sold out
Award-winning Key Lime Pie from Key West, Florida

Traditional Key Lime Pie

Regular price $29.99
Regular price $29.99 Sale price
SAVE Liquid error (snippets/price line 116): Computation results in '-Infinity'% Sold out
 
add_shopping_cart

-

Ordered

local_shipping

Local Pickup & Delivery

Within 1 Hour

redeem

Nationwide Shipping

Arrive Next Day

View full details

Order Key Lime Pie Online

Shipped Fresh From Florida

Looking for the best key lime pie delivery? You’ve found it. Our Traditional Key Lime Pie is handcrafted in Key West, Florida using a 100-year-old recipe and the freshest real key lime juice. We partner directly with Key Lime Pie Co. to bring you an authentic slice of the Florida Keys.

  • The Most Delicious Key Lime Pie

    Key Lime Pie Co. uses only the best natural ingredients in the key lime pies, making each pie handled with care. Our Key Lime Pies are made with real key lime juice, and a homemade graham cracker crust.

  • Key Lime Pie Delivery

    Award Winning Key Lime Pie

    As seen on CNBC “The Profit” with entrepreneur Marcus Lemonis & Good Morning America Food Network, get ready to enjoy the perfect combination of sweet and tart and be taken one bite at a time to the warm and breezy feels of Key West.

  • Key Lime Pie By Mail

    Made in Florida, Shipped to You

    We ship this iconic Florida Keys dessert to your house for you to enjoy any day of the year! Our expert packaging keep the Key Lime Pies fresh overnight.

    Whole Key Lime Pie Delivered Fresh Nationwide

    Looking to order key lime pie online that tastes like it came straight from a Florida bakery? Our whole Key Lime Pie delivers bold citrus flavor, creamy texture, and a perfectly buttery graham cracker crust in every slice.

    This is not just any dessert. Our pie is an award-winning Key Lime Pie, featured on CNBC’s The Profit with Marcus Lemonis and Good Morning America. Each pie is made fresh, carefully packaged for protection, and shipped overnight to ensure it arrives in peak condition.

    Why This Key Lime Pie Stands Out

    Authentic Florida-Style Key Lime Pie

    Our authentic Key Lime Pie strikes the perfect balance between tart and sweet. The smooth, citrus-forward filling pairs beautifully with a buttery graham cracker crust, creating a refreshing dessert that’s rich without being heavy.

    Made Fresh & Shipped Overnight

    Every whole Key Lime Pie is made fresh and packaged to protect its shape and texture during transit. We ship overnight to maintain quality, flavor, and presentation—because desserts this good shouldn’t sit in transit.

    Perfect For

    • Celebrations and special occasions
    • Gifts shipped nationwide
    • Dinner parties and family gatherings
    • Holiday desserts
    • Anyone craving a classic citrus dessert

    Nationwide Overnight Shipping & Miami Local Delivery

    We offer nationwide overnight shipping for our whole Key Lime Pie, carefully packaged for protection during delivery. South Florida customers can enjoy local Miami pickup or express delivery for maximum freshness.

    Your Trusted Source for Iconic Desserts & Seafood

    Holy Crab is your trusted source for iconic desserts and premium seafood. Pair your Key Lime Pie with our famous Stone Crab, Alaskan King Crab, or other seafood favorites to finish your meal on a perfect note.

    Key Lime Pie for Sale

    Key Lime Pie Delivery, Shipped to Your Door

    We offer key lime pie shipping nationwide, including:

    • Key lime pie by mail
    • Mail order key lime pie for holidays or special occasions
    • Key lime pies shipped as gifts for birthdays, corporate thank-yous, or just because

    Enjoy the tangy, creamy, and sweet taste of the Keys, no matter where you live.

    How Much is Key Lime Pie?

    Our key lime pie price is just $29.99, with the option to pair it with stone crab claws or mustard sauce for a full Florida-style seafood feast.

    Key Lime Pie Shipping

    Buy Key Lime Pie Today

    Delivered Right to Your Door

    Add this to your cart and get your key lime pie delivered fast. Whether you're looking for where to buy key lime pie, searching for the best mail order key lime pie, or craving a slice of summer, this is it.

    Why Choose Our Key Lime Pie?

    • Made in Key West, Florida
    • Shipped fresh from Florida
    • Tangy, creamy filling with a crisp graham cracker crust
    • Loved by food critics and TV personalities alike
    • Ships in eco-friendly, protective packaging