Stone Crab vs. King Crab: Which One Should You Order?

By Anna Barnett

Stone Crab vs. King Crab: Which One Should You Order?

Comparing Two Premium Crabs for the Perfect Seafood Experience

When it comes to luxury seafood, two claws reign supreme: Stone Crab and King Crab. Both are beloved for their sweet flavor and premium texture—but they deliver very different experiences.

If you're trying to decide between ordering stone crab delivery or indulging in king crab legs, this guide will break down what you need to know: taste, texture, sustainability, and what pairs best with each.

Stone Crab: The Florida Favorite

Flavor: Sweet, mild, and buttery with a firm texture
Where It’s From: Florida waters
Best Served: Chilled, cracked, with mustard sauce
Sustainability: High – only the claws are harvested; crabs are returned to the ocean

Why You’ll Love It:
Stone crab claws are a delicacy known for their clean flavor, dense texture, and sustainable harvesting method. They're served cold with our signature mustard sauce and make for an elegant, easy-to-eat centerpiece.

👉 Order Stone Crab Claws

King Crab: The Showstopper

Flavor: Rich, sweet, and succulent with a soft, flaky texture
Where It’s From: Cold waters of Alaska and the Bering Sea
Best Served: Warm with garlic butter, or chilled in a seafood tower
Sustainability: Regulated – limited season harvests ensure quality and population health

Why You’ll Love It:
King crab legs offer a visual wow factor and generous portions of sweet, buttery meat that peel right from the shell. They're perfect for surf & turf dinners, special occasions, or when you just want to go big.

👉 Shop King Crab Legs

What About Jonah Crab?

If you're looking for an affordable everyday option, Jonah crab is a flavorful alternative. It has a slightly brinier flavor and a flakier texture, making it ideal for dips, platters, or seafood boils.

👉 Explore Jonah Crab Options

Which Crab is Right for You?

Crab Type Texture Flavor Best Served Ideal For
Stone Crab Firm Mild & Sweet Chilled w/ Mustard Sauce Traditional Florida experience
King Crab Flaky & Tender Rich & Buttery Warm w/ Garlic Butter Impressing guests, Surf & Turf

 

You can’t go wrong with either—but knowing the differences can help you build your perfect seafood feast.

Perfect Crab Pairings

Whether you’re treating yourself or hosting guests, Holy Crab delivers the best claws and legs—fresh, flash-frozen, and ready to crack.

Let’s get crackin’.

Share: